Josh Dean

as Jeff

as Jeff

as Nate

as Freddy

as Jeff

as Andrew

as George

as Grant Coletti

as Rev. Peter Jackson

as Cole Peters

as Party Goer

as Josh Jo

as Todd Asher (voice)

as Jim Kogut

as Boston Arliss Crab

as Father Justin

as Josh Nally

as Rico Java (uncredited)

as Rico Java

as Andy Faust

as Nate