Christopher Rodriguez Marquette

as Self

as Eli

as Pope

as Charlie Linderman

as Hebrew Child (singing voice)

as Eddie

as Cooper

as Milo Burns

as Oliver

as Ben Roberts

as David Huttenson

as Pete Egan

as Ricky

as Jimmy Barrett

as Danny Jennings

as Carver Cruz

as Seth Tilton

as Marc Delgado

as Young Maxwell Sheffield

as Marty Dorset

as Barry Wilson

as Trip